'Public Enemies' review

Too bad John Dillinger never stole any quality scripts

By Matt Pais

Metromix
June 30, 2009

 
Critic's Rating:
2 1/2

'Public Enemies' review
Johnny Depp (Credit: Universal)
Photos:
Johnny Depp Marion Cotillard and Johnny Depp Christian Bale Billy Crudup
Public Enemies
Running time:
140 minutes
Rated:
R
Cast:
Johnny Depp -
John Dillinger
Christian Bale -
Melvin Purvis
Marion Cotillard -
Billie Frechette
Billy Crudup -
J. Edgar Hoover
Stephen Dorff -
Homer Van Meter
See full cast
Director:
Michael Mann
Genre:
Action
Official Movie Web Site:
http://www.publicenemies.net/
Movie Trailer:
Overall User Rating:
4 (11 ratings)
Write a review

By 1933 the Depression was in full swing, and bank robber John Dillinger (Johnny Depp) was something of a celebrity. (Note: The previous sentence sounds more fun if you read it in an old-timey radio voice.) The film begins with Dillinger's escape from prison in Michigan City, Ind., depicts his romance with Billie Frechette (Marion Cotillard) and pursuit by FBI Agent Melvin Purvis (Christian Bale), and leads up to Dillinger being gunned down outside Chicago's Biograph Theater in 1934.
 
The buzz: Expectations are high, and "Public Enemies" could score the rare hat trick of becoming a summer blockbuster, critical favorite and Oscar contender. In the meantime, is director/co-writer Michael Mann's latest crime drama closer to his extraordinary "Heat" or dull "Miami Vice"?
 
The verdict: Were so many details used on the production design that none were left over for the story? Sure, "Public Enemies" looks great, with Chicago (and parts of Indiana and Wisconsin) gloriously turned back to the '30s with razor-sharp precision. The script just isn't there. From Dillinger's background and supposed popularity—little is said, less is shown—to Purvis having clean-cut officers replaced with more qualified southern lawmen, everything feels underwritten, strangely edited and poorly explained. And despite very good performances from Depp and Cotillard, Dillinger's interest in Billie never translates from innocuous pick-up to true love.
 
Did you know? Dillinger demonstrates that if a public service announcement advises you that a wanted criminal could be sitting to your left or right, the guy that doesn't look is probably guilty. Watch out!

Video: Watch Matt's review of 'Public Enemies'

What other people are saying...

No-pic-dude

okvals from Mt. Prospect - July 01, 2009 at 10:35 AM

Lame script? Why don't you go into your time machine back to the early thirties, befriend Dillinger and his gang and make a better script for us. Y...

More...

Report This Comment

REDAWN from Wilton Manors - July 01, 2009 at 9:54 AM

I cannot wait to see this film and have been in love w/ Johnny Depp since A nightmare on Elm Street part one. I must see this film for myself. John...

More...

Report This Comment

saraht from Cobble Hill, Brooklyn - June 30, 2009 at 10:59 AM

I am surprised at how many reviewers are not into this movie, still going to check it out though. I love Stephen Graham who plays Baby Face Nelson.

Report This Comment

rondapenrice from Grant Park - June 30, 2009 at 10:18 AM

I caught a screening of Public Enemies at AMC Parkway Pointe last night and, though the critics are slaughtering it and my brother thought it was o...

More...

Report This Comment
No-pic-chick

CalGal from camarillo - June 30, 2009 at 2:20 AM

Hmm-a movie based on fact(but with some dramatic license of course)---shows a true scene where people in movie theaters were shown newsreels of Dil...

More...

Report This Comment

Add a comment

Please log in to comment

SHOWTIME LISTINGS

Movie theaters and showtimes for Public Enemies in Washington D.C..

Narrow search by zipcode:

No Showtimes available

PHOTO GALLERY

Star Treks: Johnny Depp

Star Treks: Johnny Depp

See how Johnny went from teen idol to 'Pirate'...

PHOTO GALLERY

Star Treks: Christian Bale

Star Treks: Christian Bale

Check out Bale before the Batsuit and 'Public...

Movie reviews

Movie reviews

Catch up on recent film reviews you might have missed the first time around.

More on Metromix.com

Ornament-bottom-yellow